Five Point Someone vs. Three Idiots
Let me disclaim this to be any tale of dunces or any equivalent form. All views have been written by a rational human being.
As I departed the Bangalore airport in March, 2007, my sister, unwillingly parted with the book by Chetan Bhagat - Five Point Someone. It had been creating raves among Indians and few Asians. Since the moment, I finished the book, there has not been a day when I have not wondered whether this book was the worst one that I had got to read. The writing and narration was irreparably mediocre. Yet, the book was a success. It was because -we have a large percentage of young populace, many aspiring to become an IITians, and also the story had romance coupled with a happy ending - recipe for immediate success on home turf. Only by a cats whister, Chetan missed out being called a Devta (God) of Indian literature.
Now, the Devta is upset that his unique story has been plagiarized by group of moviemakers - who called his tale - The three idiots. Chetan shows his benevolence, and accepts the movie, eventhough, a penny of the box-office profits wasn't shared with him. We have a martyr. Maybe build a memorial for him. Acknowledge his petty achievements as national. I am curious to know what the Sahitya academy, Man Booker and Pullitzer committee are thinking on this issue.
I have been amused at all the hoopla that the farce of a book and the movie has created. The three idiots, showcases, 40 year olds as 20 year olds - no genetic disorders of any type, and still managed to win an unaminous vote of approval. Somewhere, I believe that this generation of our society has deprecated such, that a two piece worth of art is viewed as a Rembrandt. Where has the intellect, a capacity to distinguish genuine and unworthy, disappeared. There seems to be an apalling void that has blurred the vision of the modern day, Indian populace - who seem to be retarding fast in the evolutionary cycle. This element of biology is still not understood, well enough, to provide a hypothesis. So, I call it foolhardiness and rest my case.
As I departed the Bangalore airport in March, 2007, my sister, unwillingly parted with the book by Chetan Bhagat - Five Point Someone. It had been creating raves among Indians and few Asians. Since the moment, I finished the book, there has not been a day when I have not wondered whether this book was the worst one that I had got to read. The writing and narration was irreparably mediocre. Yet, the book was a success. It was because -we have a large percentage of young populace, many aspiring to become an IITians, and also the story had romance coupled with a happy ending - recipe for immediate success on home turf. Only by a cats whister, Chetan missed out being called a Devta (God) of Indian literature.
Now, the Devta is upset that his unique story has been plagiarized by group of moviemakers - who called his tale - The three idiots. Chetan shows his benevolence, and accepts the movie, eventhough, a penny of the box-office profits wasn't shared with him. We have a martyr. Maybe build a memorial for him. Acknowledge his petty achievements as national. I am curious to know what the Sahitya academy, Man Booker and Pullitzer committee are thinking on this issue.
I have been amused at all the hoopla that the farce of a book and the movie has created. The three idiots, showcases, 40 year olds as 20 year olds - no genetic disorders of any type, and still managed to win an unaminous vote of approval. Somewhere, I believe that this generation of our society has deprecated such, that a two piece worth of art is viewed as a Rembrandt. Where has the intellect, a capacity to distinguish genuine and unworthy, disappeared. There seems to be an apalling void that has blurred the vision of the modern day, Indian populace - who seem to be retarding fast in the evolutionary cycle. This element of biology is still not understood, well enough, to provide a hypothesis. So, I call it foolhardiness and rest my case.